The Mythical Choice Unicorn
When I'm not busy being a super famous, ultra cool blogger (that Instagram Stories like, my whole life), you can find me at my day job, where I mostly work with folks who are struggling to stay in their homes, do not have a home, or, like me, are trying to find their next home. Granted, their situations tend to be very, very different from my own because my search for home is far less difficult due to economic, educational, race, and class privilege.
I often work with tenants in public housing projects, folks who are unsheltered/sheltered homeless, or those who are at imminent risk of homelessness. By contrast, I am currently very comfortably housed and there's a high likelihood that I will remain so. And due to my privilege, I more or less have a choice in where and how I am housed. Hence, the Mythical Choice Unicorn.
- If homeless people got off their lazy asses, they wouldn't be homeless. Duh.
- Why don't poor people just try harder, you know? Like, my family was poor and now they're not because hard work.
- "Poor" people are just gaming the system. They're taking advantage of us! We should have stricter regulations that will prevent them from robbing us all blind.
- People should be grateful for whatever they get! We have shelters don't we? Didn't Mayor Caldwell build those shipping container houses out at Sand Island? They should just go live there.
- Seeing all these homeless people really bums me out when:
- I'm being a crappy tourist and
consumingenjoying all of your resources and culture for my own benefit (I love luaus!), which means I'm here for paradise, not to bear witness to your problems. I'm bolstering your economy, so you need to listen to me. - I'm trying to run a business here! Homeless people deter customers from coming into my overpriced boutique in Chinatown (did you know we're the only store selling carefully curated, single batch, vintage, fair trade, handmade, locally sourced, upcycled fill-in-the-blank? Because my customer base is primarily the crappy tourists (see above) who come here, I can't have them see all these crazy/weird/smelly homeless people. I'm bolstering the economy and
gentrifyingimproving the neighborhood, so you need to listen to me. - I'm desk jockeying at my bank job in downtown. While I'm waiting for my $10 plate lunch, I really don't want to see that same homeless guy yelling at himself in the middle of Hotel St. He scares me but not enough to stop me from posting a video of him on social media for my entertainment. I'm a
jerkhard-working taxpayer that's bolstering the economy, so you need to listen to me.
Can we agree that's just totally gross? All of the above has a deep-rooted, dehumanizing foundation in racism and classism. They prioritize money over people. We believe we shouldn't have to interact with anything inconvenient, ugly, or messy so our solutions tend to focus on putting the ugly away - we push it out, cover it up, arrest/incarcerate it, or stick it in shipping containers that we wouldn't live in, but believe it's good enough for homeless people (and they should be grateful, too dammit!). And also, these statements stem from the myth that poor people are given a choice when it comes to 1) their poverty, and 2) their housing situation. All oor people choose to be poor. All homeless people choose to remain homeless. All dolphins choose to be aquatic mammals.
Recently, a family I've been working with for a very long time finally got moved into an accessible public housing unit. Several members of the family are physically handicapped and they had been waiting for almost a decade to get moved into a suitable apartment. They've been jerked around by various authorities for years - they were told they had to be on a wait list, that they required further medical verification, and (my personal favorite) that no one knew they were disabled because they were apparently using invisible wheelchairs, canes, and crutches. At first, the family was unsure about accepting the new apartment because they thought it didn't completely meet their needs. I found myself telling them they didn't have a choice. I felt like an asshole.
The truth is if they didn't take the unit that was offered, they were going to be put somewhere far worse than their current home or would be out on the street. Those are some shitty options. And that's what I mean by the "myth of choice" when it comes to poor people. What you and I consider choice is a universe away from what this family gets to choose from. Mental illness, addiction, and disability* significantly limit those choices even further and our systems are set up to perpetuate poverty in this way. There's not enough time (or energy left, frankly) to take the conversation to the actual economics of poverty and capitalism, but I'm hoping to at least make people think about the ways we actively and consciously participate in these systems. If we find ourselves feeling uncomfortable when we walk by a homeless encampment on our way to happy hour, we should stop and ask why. I know I'm working on this.
And later, more on aquatic mammals...
Recently, a family I've been working with for a very long time finally got moved into an accessible public housing unit. Several members of the family are physically handicapped and they had been waiting for almost a decade to get moved into a suitable apartment. They've been jerked around by various authorities for years - they were told they had to be on a wait list, that they required further medical verification, and (my personal favorite) that no one knew they were disabled because they were apparently using invisible wheelchairs, canes, and crutches. At first, the family was unsure about accepting the new apartment because they thought it didn't completely meet their needs. I found myself telling them they didn't have a choice. I felt like an asshole.
The truth is if they didn't take the unit that was offered, they were going to be put somewhere far worse than their current home or would be out on the street. Those are some shitty options. And that's what I mean by the "myth of choice" when it comes to poor people. What you and I consider choice is a universe away from what this family gets to choose from. Mental illness, addiction, and disability* significantly limit those choices even further and our systems are set up to perpetuate poverty in this way. There's not enough time (or energy left, frankly) to take the conversation to the actual economics of poverty and capitalism, but I'm hoping to at least make people think about the ways we actively and consciously participate in these systems. If we find ourselves feeling uncomfortable when we walk by a homeless encampment on our way to happy hour, we should stop and ask why. I know I'm working on this.
And later, more on aquatic mammals...

